In Class Lab 11/10 Tim Wise
What ARGUMENTS does the author make? He has a
stance as whether or not we should use the N-word as white people. His position
is that white people should not use that word, it is none or our business. Yes
by answering these questions we will be analyzing.
How persuasive do you find the argument? It is
very persuasive, Tim Wise gives a lot of examples and he is very informed with
his argument. He also wrote a book and during the video he would quote some
lines from it. None of Tim’s assumptions are questionable, he seems credible.
His white friend didn’t understand why he couldn’t use that word even though
his friends (black or white) used that word. It like his analogy with your mom,
you can say whatever you want about your own mom but no one else dares or you
will be very upset. “His Jewish grandfather can make jokes about Jews, but the
local Christian church cannot”.
What is the authors STANCE? Tim is very biased.
Any argument is biased in its own way. Since Tim is from the south, he knows
the community and how they can use the N-word or certain phrases that have a
negative effect on certain communities. Tim Wise does consider the opposing
views, he talks about how some white people think they are helping the black
community by saying it. Tim acknowledged other viewpoints but he only cited his
own.
Does the publisher bring a certain stance to the work? The
book publisher(s) had to have agreed with Tim and his stance in some way.
Do you recognize ideas you’ve run across in other
sources? We know that as white people we don’t have the right to say
the N-word.
Does this source support or challenge your own position? We
agree with his
What can you tell about the intended AUDIENCE and
PURPOSE? The audience is mainly white people. The purpose is to
convince white people that they have no right to use that word. We are members
of the audience addressed. The main purpose is to argue a certain point.
No comments:
Post a Comment